Sunday, April 05, 2015
Tori Amos wrote
extensively in her first music album about the nastiness that she had
faced in school. To this nastiness, there were any number of
explanations given. The most famous ones – made by Andrea Dworkin
and Naomi Wolf – implicated either men as such or beauty as such.
Both are wrong.
There are many men
who are not nasty to women, me being one of them. As for beauty, this
was perhaps one of the most wrongful analyses in all of history.
Beauty has existed long before 1980s, and it has also existed outside
the Western civilization and outside patriarchial society. And within
the history of the Western civilization itself, it was the times
favoring beauty – the Renaissance, the Romantic era, the early 20th
century and 1960s and 1970s – that were most favorable to women.
There is nothing
wrong with using something that one is strong in – such as, in
these women's case, the brain – to compensate for what something
that one is weak in – such as, in these women's case, beauty. But
the brain needs to come up with rightful rather than wrongful
analyses. Beauty did not cause fascist school cultures; fascism did.
And in implicating beauty as such, are attacked many good people,
many of whom, as I have discovered, have compassion for those who
have less than they do and are willing to do much to help.
The artistic
perspective supports both beauty and compassion. Having known two
genius-level woman artists who were both also exceptionally
beautiful, I've seen in them wonderful personal qualities. They were
kind, warm, compassionate and giving. They went out of their way
constantly to help people who had less than they did. It is
absolutely wrong that they be equated with abusive school bullies or
with fascists who have developed these ignorant school cultures.
It is likewise
absolutely wrong to equate beauty with stupidity. Russian women are
both beautiful and smart. In attacking beauty in the name of
intelligence, these feminists create a false dichotomy between
intelligence and beauty. This dichotomy is very wrong. There is no
correlation between intelligence and beauty. One can be smart and
beautiful; smart but not beautiful; beautiful but not smart; or
neither smart nor beautiful. Being beautiful does not make one dumb,
and being unattractive does not make one intelligent.
People have right to
empower themselves against their aggressors, and that most certainly
is the case with people at the receiving end of these school
cultures. However many of these women became aggressors themselves
and have been maliciously abusing the beautiful women, especially
ones also gifted with sensitivity. It is important that the less
attractive women not be subject to bullying; it is also important
that the more attractive women not be subject to bullying as well.
Feminism needs to
affirm all women, and that also includes the attractive ones. Being
beautiful does not make one an enemy of other women. Many beautiful
women are also beautiful human beings, and they should be treated as
such.
0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home